New Posts on Wednesdays and Saturdays -- er generally

Thursday, April 27, 2006

The Chicken or the Egg

I sometimes skim through blogs I haven't bookmarked and later am not even sure where all I have been; and this week I went to one that posed a question. When I read it, I thought it was something to think about but later it stayed with me and I thought on it more. Unfortunately because of how I found it (off Sacred Ordinary's links if you want to go hunting), I can't give anyone credit for it; and since I am paraphrasing the thought as I understood it, maybe they'd not want credit. Here it is--

Does who you are influence more what you will do or is it the other way around, and what you do makes you become who you are?

The author of the blog had one opinion in answer to evidently a comment in her/his blog where the writer had a different belief. Since I was in skim mode, I think the blog writer believed what you do had the most influence and the commenter had said it was who you are.

It's a chicken or an egg situation and probably can't be proven, but I believe it's what you do that makes the most difference and you can change who you are with your actions-- to the good or bad. If you believe in truth, be truthful and whether you have all your life had a problem with lying, you will become someone who is truthful. On the other hand, that first little lie can slide you into a place where you become someone you never dreamed you'd be. I think you see that in politics with some who started out seeming to be honorable people but they chose actions wrongly and became someone they probably never dreamed they'd be.

I think looking at our actions is very important to being the person we want to be. And yes, the Bible says our attitude is more important than what we do in terms of sin, but I believe what we do, as an act of will, can change our attitude and have proven it to myself various times on at least small things. Now did I desire to change who I was because of who I was on a deeper level or... That's the part you can't prove one way or the other.

So any opinions... chicken or egg?

3 comments:

groundhogger said...

Do you feel more now like you did when you got here, or do you feel more like you did when you got here than you do now?

My blog is warpedinblue
name: bluewarp
I believe you might be cool

Fran said...

This a paradoxical question to me since I have often been labeled as a human doing. I think I could logically build a case to support each premise. That may have been Kathryn's A Mindful Life where you saw this.

I am thrown back to faith versus good works. I have always believed faith equates to good works. Can't think of this too long tonight or I won't sleep again. Been a bitch of a couple days.

Mary Lou said...

(Fran I agree, it has been a Bitch of a week!!)

I think that we all have choices, and the circumstances you are in play a big role on who we are and what we do. If we make a wrong choice, then it will sit on our conscience until we change what we do to become who we really were.

I hope! maybe.

Jeez, so much thinking so early!!